Stories or instruction? How authors found the balance in their nonfiction books
Every expert's first draft leans one way. Some read like a manual: correct, complete and hard to finish. Others are a string of great stories that leave the reader unsure what to do. The authors below landed at different points between the two. Seeing where each one ended up, and why, makes it easier to place your own book.
The quotes come from Author Hour, Scribe Media's podcast with people who have published books. Several of these authors worked with Scribe, which sells book services. The decision belongs in Module 4, usually during your first revision pass, when you can see the whole draft and how it reads.
Position 1: "My draft was a manual, and it was boring"
This is the most common starting point for experts, and two authors described hitting it head on. Pat Strubbe, a retirement planner, reread his first chapter with fresh eyes.
I did my first chapter of my first draft, I thought it was really good and then I went back and read it and I thought, “This is the most boring thing I’ve ever read in my entire life.” That’s when I changed my first book into more of a story
John Gatewood had written for his financial firm for decades, so he did not lack writing practice. His first draft still came out the same way.
When I wrote the book, my first draft, I wrote it and it was more instructional.
Gatewood said the best advice he got from his editor was to make it read more like a story, the way a novel pulls you along. His summary of the shift: I'm not just writing a textbook, right?
Instruction on its own is easy to write and hard to read. Readers keep turning pages because they want to know what happened to someone. A teaching book can use that pull: open a chapter with a real situation, teach the principle it shows, then return to the situation to show the outcome.
Position 2: "Story carries the lessons"
Some authors go further and build the whole book around a narrative. Jeffrey Meyerson wrote about how a large technology company builds software, and he used the company's story as the spine.
By framing the book around that entertaining storyline, it creates ample opportunity to do these many case studies, these many lessons, these many takeaways
This works when a real sequence of events naturally teaches your ideas in order. It is harder to pull off when your method has steps that do not line up with any single story.
Position 3: "The stories were so good, readers forgot the point"
Stories have a risk too. Mike Carpenter's early readers enjoyed his stories, and that was the problem.
The reason I did that is that when I got through in the pair reviews was yeah, the stories were super entertaining, but sometimes they got so entertained by the stories they forgot what it was about.
His fix was a key takeaways section at the end, a summary readers can return to without rereading every story. Inside chapters, the same fix works on a smaller scale: after each story, state the lesson in a sentence or two. Never make the reader guess why you told it.
Position 4: "Case studies, but kept outside the book"
Scott A. Martin got advice from another author not to fill his book with case studies, because examples date and he wanted the book to last. He agreed with the goal.
And I said, yeah, my goal is to make it a foundational, timeless book. I don't want it to be out of date.
His solution was to keep the case studies in a free online area for readers, organized chapter by chapter to match the book, where he can add new ones. That suits fields that change often, where a named company example can look stale within a few years. Stories about people and principles tend to age better than stories about specific tools or market conditions.
Position 5: "No stories at all"
At the far end is Natasha Adamo, a breakup coach, who chose to write a book with no stories or case studies, against the advice of the publishers who turned her down.
they said, “You know, you need case studies, this book will never survive without case studies.”
Adamo said her readers come to the book in the middle of a crisis and want direct help, not other people's stories, and that she made the book entirely about the reader. It is a deliberate choice for a specific reader in a specific state of mind. For most expert books, it is the riskier end of the scale, but it is a reminder that the right balance depends on what your reader is feeling when they pick the book up.
Finding your position
Ask three questions about your reader, then check your draft against the answers.
- How does the reader arrive? Curious and unhurried readers welcome stories. Readers in urgent trouble want the steps sooner.
- Does your method follow a real sequence of events? If yes, a single narrative can carry it. If not, use a story per chapter instead.
- How long should the book stay current? Favor stories about people and decisions over named tools, prices or companies, or keep dated examples outside the book.
Then do this revision pass on your draft:
- Every chapter opens with a person in a situation, unless you chose Position 5 on purpose.
- Every story ends with its lesson stated plainly.
- No chapter is only instruction for more than a few pages without an example.
- The end of the book, or the end of each chapter, gives the reader the takeaways in brief.
For where to place a personal story about yourself, rather than a client's, see how much of your own story belongs in your book.
Sources: Author Hour episodes linked beside each quote, checked November 16, 2026. Quotes are verbatim; other descriptions summarize what each author said. Published by Scribe Media.