Guide · Goes with Modules 1 and 4

How much of your own story belongs in your nonfiction book? Four questions authors faced

Most experts get this wrong in one of two directions. Some write a memoir when they meant to write a guide. Others hide behind their ideas and leave the reader wondering who is talking. The authors below hit both problems and fixed them. Their experience boils down to four questions you can answer about your own book.

The authors quoted here were guests on Author Hour, Scribe Media's podcast with people who have published books, most of them with Scribe's help. Scribe sells book services; this course is free either way. The decision itself belongs in Module 1, when you define what the book is, and it comes back in Module 4, when you see the draft on the page.

Question 1: Is this a memoir, or a book that teaches?

This sounds like an obvious question, and plenty of authors answer it wrong without noticing. Jim Sholler wrote a book teaching a method for solving problems at work. His sister read his first draft and asked him the question directly.

She was the one who gave me the first feedback year, read the first draft and said, are you writing a memoir or do you want to train people? And I said, no, no, no, it's not a memoir. And she goes, all right, we have to start over.

Your life story is the material you know best, so it pours out first. That is fine in a draft. But if the book's job is to teach, every personal story has to earn its place by serving the lesson. Go back to the objective you wrote in Module 1. If it says the reader should be able to do something after reading, the book is a teaching book, and your story is supporting evidence, not the main line.

Your answer: write one sentence: "This book teaches [reader] to [do something]." Then highlight every page of your draft or outline that is about you. If more than a third is highlighted, ask whether each story is there for the reader or for you.

Question 2: Does the reader need to know who you are before they trust you?

Usually, yes, at least a little. Mark Briggs had not planned to open with his own life at all. Then, while outlining, he asked the question every reader asks.

I figured I needed to set up and establish the credibility of like why should anyone listen to me.

Briggs said it was terrifying to write, and that it felt right once it was on the page. That is a common pattern. The personal background that answers "why listen to you" usually belongs early, often in the introduction, and it does not need to be long. It needs to show that you have been where the reader is, or that you have done the thing you are teaching.

Your answer: list the two or three experiences that qualify you to write this book for this reader. Those go in the introduction. The rest of your life story waits until a chapter needs it.

Question 3: Are you hiding behind your ideas?

The opposite problem is just as common, especially among experts who are modest or private. Ryan Bisio wrote a book connecting basketball and music, and his first instinct was to keep himself out of it.

My instinct was to make the book about my ideas and just let the ideas stand for themselves.

He said his ideas were abstract on their own, and that they only came alive once he added chapters about specific games and his own stories from the music business. When his editors told him the book needed more of him, he resisted at first.

And I was like, oh, I don't know. It's not about me. It's about the ideas. No, I was dead wrong.

The test here is abstraction. If a chapter explains a principle without a single scene, a person, a place or a moment, readers will struggle to remember it. Your own experience is usually the most vivid example you have, and it is one nobody else can use.

Your answer: for each chapter in your outline, write down one moment from your own work that shows the chapter's point. If you cannot find one, that is a sign the chapter is either too abstract or not really yours to write.

Question 4: How much detail, and how much stays private?

Once a story is in, you still have to decide how deep to go. Maranda Dziekonski's life had more than enough drama for a memoir. She chose to write a business book instead, and cut accordingly. She said she kept small pieces of her life story in, enough for readers to understand where she was coming from.

Of course, I cut a lot of stuff out for this book to make it more of a business memoir.

Lona Cook went the other way. She deliberately kept some parts of her story vague, and her editors pushed her to say more. She described the moment she understood why.

So, I had to realize that I’m asking people, by reading this book, to hopefully look at their own stories and to integrate some of the things that maybe we feel shame or guilt or reservation about in our own past in order to hopefully create a better next step for yourself.

Both choices were right for their books. The difference is what the book asks of the reader. Dziekonski's book asks leaders to learn from her career, so a little personal context is enough. Cook's book asks readers to face their own past, which they will not do if the author holds back. Match your openness to what you are asking the reader to do.

Your answer: write down what your book asks the reader to do or face. Then, for each personal story, decide: does the reader need the full version, or just enough to understand where I am coming from? Remember that other people in your stories have a say too. Change names and details where you need to.

A short self-check

  • I can say in one sentence whether this book teaches or tells my story.
  • The introduction answers "why listen to me" in a page or two.
  • Every chapter has at least one moment from my own experience.
  • No chapter is mostly about me unless the book is a memoir.
  • The depth of each personal story matches what I am asking of the reader.
  • People in my stories are protected, or have agreed to be named.

The Scribe Method, Scribe's free book on writing nonfiction, has a full chapter on how much of your story should be in your book if you want to go deeper.

Sources: Author Hour episodes linked beside each quote, checked November 16, 2026. Quotes are verbatim; other descriptions summarize what each author said. Published by Scribe Media.