The publishing decisions first-time authors did not expect, and how to prepare for them
By the time the manuscript is locked, most authors feel the hard part is over. Then the questions start: cream or white paper, which of these covers, will you narrate the audiobook yourself? None of them is difficult on its own. Together, they surprise almost everyone. Here is what authors said caught them off guard, and how to be ready.
The authors quoted here were guests on Author Hour, Scribe Media's podcast with people who have published books. Most published with Scribe, which sells publishing services, so some details reflect that process. The decisions themselves are the same whichever publishing path in Module 5 you choose, and if you self-publish, you make every one of them yourself.
Surprise 1: how many small decisions there are
Maranda Dziekonski, a technology executive, put it simply.
I had no idea about all the little things, the decisions I would have to make. Everything from, do you want white paper to what is the other option? Cream.
She listed photos, the cover, its design and the author bios too, and summed it up: But there's so much more to it than just putting words on paper.
Joy Lane, a senior design engineer who takes products from concept to launch for a living, assumed she would be ready for this stage. The paper question stopped her too.
And then for a book, watching that come together, the layout, you know, they're asking me questions like, what color do you want the pages, cream or white? You know, and I was like, I don't know. I don't care. What do you think? So I do care.
"I don't care. What do you think? So I do care" is how many authors feel about a dozen choices in a row. Prepare: before production starts, pick three books in your category that you like holding. Note their trim size, paper color, font feel and cover finish. When the questions come, you can answer "like this one" instead of guessing. The glossary explains the terms you will hear, such as trim size and interior layout.
Surprise 2: the cover takes rounds, and you may still second-guess it
Lane said the cover took months to get right. She had an idea, an image of engineering paper, that meant something to her but could mean anything to anyone else, and a cover artist had to help draw out what she meant.
Kristin Birdwell started her cover from an idea a friend suggested over lunch, gave it to the designer, and chose from what came back. She enjoyed the process, and was candid about how she feels now.
Going through the cover design process is really cool though. Although now I'm like, would I have, would I choose the same cover? Maybe not.
Second thoughts are normal. A cover has to work as a tiny image on a store page, on a shelf, and on your own website, and your taste will keep moving after it is printed. Prepare: write a short cover brief before the designer starts: the reader, three comparable covers you admire and why, the one feeling the cover must give, and anything you do not want. Judge every option at thumbnail size, the way most readers first see it. Ask two people who match your reader, not just friends.
Surprise 3: recording the audiobook is its own project
If you narrate your own audiobook, you will read every word of the book aloud in a studio. Dr. Monifa McKnight said she was not an audiobook listener before she went in, and that the recording surprised her.
When I went in for the audio recording, and I'm not an audio book person. I wish I were before I went into that recording. But boy, was it a learning experience.
She also said reading her own story aloud meant reliving it again, and she credited a patient producer who gave her breaks. For authors of personal books, that is worth knowing in advance.
Bryan Miles narrated the audiobook of Virtual Culture himself (Author Hour interview) and pointed to the reason many authors choose to: if you like my voice, you can hear me talk to you as I read the whole book to you.
Readers who already know you from talks or podcasts often prefer your voice.
Prepare: listen to two or three audiobooks in your category, including one narrated by its author. Read a chapter of your own book aloud at home and time it. If you stumble on sentences, mark them now; they may need a light edit for the ear. Ask how many studio sessions to expect and plan rest days between them.
Surprise 4: the book's look has to travel
Gino Barbaro, who writes about real estate investing, said the book's design is part of its marketing, and admitted his team missed one piece.
So if you're writing a book and it has specific colors, specific fonts, specific fields, that has to translate onto the website. And that's something that we didn't do as well, but the book was just beautifully done.
Prepare: when the cover is final, ask the designer for the colors and fonts used, and the files you will need for your website, social profiles, slides and a book page. Doing this during production is easier than chasing it after launch, when Module 6 keeps you busy.
Surprise 5: the box of books
The last surprise is a good one. Dziekonski said It was so surreal when the box came and I opened it up and there were these books.
Plan to be there when it arrives. Then check the printed copy carefully before you order more: cover color, spine text, page order and any last typos. Proofs exist for a reason.
Your Module 5 pre-decision list
- Three books you like holding, with trim size, paper color and finish noted.
- A cover brief: reader, three comparable covers, one feeling, things to avoid.
- Two reader-matched people lined up to judge cover options.
- A decision on narrating the audiobook yourself, after reading a chapter aloud.
- A list of brand files to collect from the designer: colors, fonts, images.
- Time set aside to check the first printed copy.
The full step-by-step is in Module 5: Publish.
Sources: Author Hour episodes linked beside each quote, checked November 16, 2026. Quotes are verbatim; other descriptions summarize what each author said. Published by Scribe Media.