Guide · Goes with Modules 1 and 2

Should you give away your best ideas in your book? Four fears, and what authors found

If you sell your expertise, writing it all down can feel like handing out the keys. The authors below had the same worry. Most of them decided to hold nothing back, and they describe what happened next. One of them adds an important limit: giving everything away is not the same as putting everything in.

These quotes come from Author Hour, Scribe Media's podcast with people who have published books. Scribe sells book services, and this course is free either way. What each author says happened is their own account, not a promise of what a book will do for you. This decision belongs in Module 1, where you set the book's objectives, and in Module 2, where you decide what makes it worth buying.

Fear 1: "If I explain everything, nobody will need to hire me"

This is the big one, and the authors who tested it mostly found the opposite. Cameron Herold, who coaches company leaders, wrote his book to establish credibility. He described what he put in it and what followed.

So when I wrote the book, I put everything there. I gave every system, every cheat sheet, everything that I've used over the years to coach and help companies. And what's ended up happening is they end up hiring me to speak about the same content that's in a $25 book, or they ended up paying me $50,000 a year to coach them on the same content that's in the $25 book.

The figures are his. The logic is what matters for your book. Knowing what to do is rarely what stops people. Doing it, in their own situation, with someone experienced beside them, is. A book that explains the whole method shows readers that you know it, and the readers who want help doing it know exactly who to call.

Bill Flynn, who coaches growing companies, built that choice into his book. He added exercises and an online resource area so readers could do the work themselves, and he was relaxed about which way they went.

So you can, for all the DIY people out there, they can just do it themselves if they want or if they want to hire a coach like me, if I am available or whatever, great.

Marie Wiese, author of You Can't Be Everywhere, described the same pattern in her business (Author Hour interview). Her speaking leads to book sales, and the book leads to conversations about her method, whether they do it themselves or whether they want help. Both outcomes count as a win if the book was written to help.

Fear 2: "Competitors will read it and copy me"

Some will. The authors who addressed this head on decided it did not matter much. Simon Ree, a trader and martial arts instructor, drew on an old tradition he rejects.

I mean, there was this old thing in Chinese Kung Fu that the Kung Fu master would never reveal everything to his student, he’d always keep some secrets back.

Ree said he takes the opposite approach and holds nothing back when he teaches. Kim Butler said much the same about real estate and life insurance advice.

We love sharing it and we’re well aware that there are other real estate people. And other life insurance people out there that can do our work and we encourage that.

There is a practical point under the generosity. A competitor who copies your method still lacks your experience, your stories and your name on the cover. Readers who want your way of doing it will still look for you. And a book that holds back reads like a sales brochure, which readers notice and reviewers mention.

Fear 3: "A teaser is safer than the real thing"

Some experts plan a book that hints at their method and asks readers to call for the rest. Allison Task, a career and life coach, went the other way on purpose. She said she only takes on a small number of private clients, and she wanted the book to reach people who would never sit in her office.

I wanted to create a DIY coach, a coach in your pocket, a coaching guide. Using the tools that I’ve used with my clients and I know that they work.

A teaser book has a problem: it fails the reader. Someone who pays for a book and finishes it unable to act feels misled, and that is a poor first impression for a future client. A book that genuinely works on its own earns trust, and trust is what turns a reader into a client later.

Fear 4: "If I give everything, the book has to hold everything"

Here is the limit. Holding nothing back is not the same as putting every idea in. Scott A. Martin, a marketing strategist, wanted to pour all his knowledge into his book. His first draft read, he said he was told, like a textbook for experts, when his readers were founders who needed it simple.

And what I realized was, it's not what I want to say. It's what they need to hear.

Martin said the extra material did not disappear. He moved it to a workbook, a digital version or his consulting. That is the useful version of "give it all away": give the reader everything they need to get the result the book promises, and nothing that only shows off how much you know.

Deciding for your own book

  1. Write the book's promise in one sentence. Use your positioning statement from Module 1.
  2. List everything the reader needs to get that result. All of it goes in, including your best methods.
  3. List what you know that the reader does not need. That goes in a workbook, an appendix, a talk or your client work.
  4. Check for teasing. If any chapter ends with "to learn more, contact me," rewrite it so it stands on its own.
  5. Say how readers can go further, once, plainly, near the end: exercises, resources, and how to reach you.

The Scribe Method covers the same question in its chapter on how much you should give away in your book.

Sources: Author Hour episodes linked beside each quote, checked November 16, 2026. Results described are the authors' own claims. Published by Scribe Media.